The teacher and the surprisingly honest student
Mrs. Carter was teaching her class about honesty.
She explained that telling the truth was always better than making excuses.
“To test your understanding,” she announced, “I want each of you to give me an example of honesty.”
Little Tommy raised his hand immediately.
“Honesty means telling the truth, even when you’re afraid of getting into trouble,” he said.
“Excellent, Tommy!” Mrs. Carter replied. “Can you give us an example?”
Tommy nodded. “Yesterday, my father asked whether I’d broken his favorite coffee mug.”
“And what did you say?” the teacher asked.
“I told him the truth. I said I didn’t know how it broke.”
Mrs. Carter frowned. “But did you break it?”
Tommy looked at the floor. “Well, yes.”
“Then you didn’t tell the whole truth!”
Tommy shook his head. “I did tell the truth. I really didn’t know how it broke. I threw a ball, it hit the shelf, the mug fell, and then it broke.”
The entire class burst out laughing.
Mrs. Carter tried to remain serious. “Tommy, you should have explained everything from the beginning.”
Tommy nodded thoughtfully. “You’re right, Mrs. Carter. My father said exactly the same thing.”
“I’m glad he taught you that lesson,” she replied.
Tommy smiled. “He also said I should never play ball inside the house again.”
“That’s a sensible rule,” Mrs. Carter said.
Tommy sighed. “I know. But I think my father needs to learn about honesty, too.”
The teacher raised an eyebrow. “Why?”
Tommy answered, “Because he told Mom the mug was already cracked before I threw the ball!”
